Powering Up! with Anne Doyle
Listen to Anne's new podcast!Powering Up! with Anne Doyle
Join Anne's Network

On Anne's Mind

Old Economy Cultures Are Dead Weight in Race for 21st Century Talent

Thursday, November 30, 2006 @ 3:54 PM
How do you define work culture?  How do you know when it is a positive force in your professional environment, enhancing the ability of people to do great work? 

How do you sense when your culture, which silently influences every decision, every relationship, every individual performer, has become dead weight, rather than high-octane fuel? 

What are the warning signs, the canaries singing in the mine that alert you when cultural “oxygen” is getting dangerously low?

I’m thinking a lot about business cultures these days, because my home base is Detroit, the Motor City, the nerve center of the North American Auto Industry.  The once mighty “Big Three” automakers, General Motors, Ford and Chrysler (now part of Daimler Chrysler), are undergoing wrenching downsizing.  

Thousands, many second and third generation employees, have lost their jobs.  Michigan’s economy has nearly been brought to its knees, with the highest unemployment rate (6.9%) in the country.  This reckoning has been coming for years.  Changing leaders never seemed to stem the steady decline.  

Beneath the headlines and short-term restructuring shocks, a silent shift is occurring within these huge companies.  A shift which is a danger signal as disturbing as the quieting of a canary in a mine.

Once proud companies that attracted the best and the brightest to their management ranks, the domestic auto companies are losing today’s talent and the ability to attract tomorrow’s top talent.  Notably, significant numbers of women executives are choosing to leave the industry, as I wrote in an opinion piece for Automotive News (see Oct.  22nd link on website).  Crain’s Detroit Business expanded on the theme this week, “Uncertainty leads to exits . . . execs look for greener pastures” (www.crainsdetroit.com).  

Before I commented publicly on the industry’s loss of women leaders, I spoke to nearly three dozen high-level automotive women, many who have recently left for other industries. Although they prefer not to be quoted publicly, they were quite blunt about the automotive work cultures, telling me:

“Management doesn’t even realize how they self-select people just like them.”

“Male dominated thinking remains at the core of how decisions are made and things get done.”

“It’s a fight every day.”

“The culture doesn’t know how to receive creativity and innovation.  People who try to put it forth have to brace themselves for combat.”

“When times are tough, they are unwilling to take a chance with people.  They stick with their comfort levels, guys who are part of “the team” and operate just like them.”

“It is hard for somebody not like them to have much impact.”

“We’ve really gone backward.”

“The culture is never going to change until significant numbers of women and minorities move into high levels of management.”

“Women know a lost cause when they see it.” 

Survival in the fiercely competitive global auto industry, of course, is Job One.  But right on its heels in urgency is the transformation of these old economy corporate cultures to environments that can effectively attract, develop and retain 21st century talent. 

We all know there’s a talent shortage coming.  A “war” for top talent on the horizon.  But the next generation of emerging leaders, the most diverse the business world has ever seen, won’t settle for static, traditional, homogeneous work cultures.   

Old economy industries, such as the U.S. auto companies, have nearly century-old work cultures, which are male-dominated, hierarchical, and depend on well-developed networks of personal connections for work to get done. They are insular environments, where careers are built over decades and the levels on the corporate ladder are well-defined. Those tapped and developed as future leaders somehow look and operate very much like those doing the tapping and mentoring.  Loyalties run deep, developed through many years of working together through the ups and downs of the industry.  Thus, the good old boys network. 

Culture is about the way work gets done.  How people work together.  How information is shared.  Respect for individuals.  The way creativity is channeled.  How debate plays out, as intellectual wrestling for breakthrough thinking or political power struggles.  It’s about who and what are rewarded.

Survival in a fiercely competitive global business has to be Job One for U.S. automakers.  But transforming their cultures, which have become dead weights in their race to restore these once proud companies to health, has to be Job Two. 

Culture, in my book, is the oxygen that everyone breaths.  It can be energizing or toxic.  The faster you need to run, the better your oxygen supply must be.  How are the canaries doing in your work environment?

Leadership Feedback

Anne is interested in your leadership feedback. Periodically, we'll post a new question; we look forward to hearing your responses.

» Click here to view our current question...

Previous Entries

» 12/13/2018 - Bridging the Millennial/Baby Boomer Divide
» 9/26/2018 - #MeToo and Speaking Truth to Power
» 6/3/2018 - That's What She Said
» 4/6/2018 - The Time is Always Right to Do What is Right
» 1/29/2018 - The Rage & Resilience of Gymnast Sister Survivors
» 1/8/2018 - Oprah for President. Really!!!
» 12/23/2017 - What's Next After #MeToo?
» 10/13/2017 - Bullying Boys and Bystander Enablers
» 4/13/2017 - Gold Medal Sistering
» 3/22/2017 - A Severe Case of Testosterone Poisoning
» 11/15/2016 - The Anticipated Roar That Dissolved To A Whisper
» 10/16/2016 - Hear Us Roar!
» 9/11/2016 - It's Time for Women to Stop Being Politely Angry
» 6/7/2016 - Hillary Makes His ... er... Herstory!
» 4/20/2016 - On the Eve of Significant Leadership Change
» 11/22/2015 - There But For The Grace of God Go We
» 5/29/2015 - UBUNTU: I Am Because You Are
» 4/8/2015 - Death By A Thousand Cuts
» 1/9/2015 - Dare to Raise Your Voice MORE in 2015
» 11/16/2014 - Global Women Leaders Gather & Gamergate Backlash
» 8/10/2014 - Relentless Incrementalism
» 5/8/2014 - Thoughts on Mothers and Mothering
» 12/6/2013 - We All Have the Power In Us To Change the Tide, says Nobel Peace Laureate Leymah Gbowee
» 10/14/2013 - Terrific, Fresh Insight From Four Women Execs
» 8/21/2013 - Harvard Business Review Fresh Insight on Women Rising
» 6/7/2013 - Behind Black Robes, Hijabs And Niqabs, Saudi Women Are Dreaming Big
» 4/16/2013 - When Amway and Microsoft Team Up For Women's Leadership, Sky's the Limit
» 2/25/2013 - NASCAR'S Danica Patrick & Dad's Empower Daughters
» 1/24/2013 - Time For Sports To Stop Limiting Women to Sideline Eye Candy
» 1/2/2013 - The Human Family is Crying Out for Women to Step Up
» 12/2/2012 - Radio Interview with Emily Gail, ESPN Radio Hawaii
» 11/5/2012 - Mixing Business With Pleasure. It's Routine for Men. Why Do Women Hesitate?
» 6/24/2012 - Don't Say Vagina in Michigan and Don't Sit At Men-Only Tables
» 3/17/2012 - St. Patrick's Day Reminder of My Greatest Mentor
» 3/11/2012 - 2012 Women in the World Summit Filled With Riveting Moments
» 2/8/2012 - Overcoming the Gender Ambition Gap
» 10/16/2011 - WOMEN, WAR AND PEACE
» 9/28/2011 - Women with "Ganas" Are Leaders & Engines of Economic Growth
» 9/27/2011 - Dale Carnegie Words of Wisdom
» 8/13/2011 - Focus Hope's Eleanor Josaitis Refused To Be A Spectator
» 6/20/2011 - What Makes Teams Smarter? More Women, says Harvard Business Review
» 5/16/2011 - Women Are Not "Guys" and Men are Not "The Norm"
» 3/19/2011 - Anything is Possible Interview with WJR's Jack Krasula
» 2/26/2011 - Interview with National Women's Radio
» 1/28/2011 - Women Play Equal Role in Tunisia Revolution
» 1/10/2011 - As Women in High-Profile Leadership Increase, So Do the Risks
» 1/1/2011 - Leadership Award Winner Helen Mirren Lets Hollywood Have it . . . With a Grin
» 11/4/2010 - I Had the Pleasure of Knowing Sparky Anderson
» 10/28/2010 - Leadership at all Levels Behind Ford Motor's Stunning Turnaround
» 9/15/2010 - Weighing in on NY Jets Harassment of TV Azteca Sports Reporter
» 7/13/2010 - The Economic Recovery Will be Female
» 5/10/2010 - Auto Industry Still Driving Best and the Brightest Women Out
» 4/1/2010 - Let Sports Arenas Unite, Not Further Divide
» 3/6/2010 - Pass Your Power Forward
» 2/3/2010 - The Girl Cell: I Am An Emotional Creature
» 10/20/2009 - The Torch is Being Passed . . . To a New Gender
» 9/7/2009 - Diane Sawyer Named New ABC Nightly News Anchor
» 8/31/2009 - Nothing LIke a Scandal to Get Michigan Football Fans Stirred Up
» 7/25/2009 - Was ESPN's Erin Andrews "Asking for it?"
» 7/14/2009 - History Awaits Sonia Sotomayor
» 6/15/2009 - The Meaning of Michelle, Sonia, Ursula and Anne
» 5/20/2009 - Getting Beyond Gender, to Agenda
» 5/11/2009 - Let's Take Back Mother's Day
» 3/19/2009 - Expect To Be Tested
» 2/27/2009 - I thought I had no time for LinkedIn or Facebook -- let alone Twitter! Boy was I wrong.
» 1/28/2009 - Women's Leadership in the Age of Obama
» 1/20/2009 - Interview with Founding President of the Women's Media Center
» 1/11/2009 - One Gender's Crash
» 12/18/2008 - Caroline Kennedy's Biological Clock Powers Up
» 11/23/2008 - The Ascent of a Woman: Lessons I've Learned from Hillary
» 11/2/2008 - The Power of Perseverance
» 10/31/2008 - Gloria, Billie Jean, Oprah and Maria all together
» 10/22/2008 - Tina Fey and the Real Sarah Palin
» 9/30/2008 - Most Poweful Women
» 9/5/2008 - Weighing in on Sarah Palin
» 8/25/2008 - Rachel Maddow Rocks
» 7/15/2008 - Never Eliminate Yourself
» 6/3/2008 - Show Me A Good Loser and I'll Show You A Loser
» 5/16/2008 - Obama Better Break Not So Sweet Habit
» 4/8/2008 - The Man Keeps His Mansion, The Woman Almost Gets Tethered
» 1/8/2008 - The Soul of a Leader
» 12/11/2007 - All I Want for Christmas Is . . .
» 10/26/2007 - Dare to Lead. A simple but compelling message.
» 9/25/2007 - The Gender Tipping Point . . . just an election away?
» 6/17/2007 - Return to Traditions Can Have Chilling Under Currents
» 5/21/2007 - Queen Rania, Future of the Arab World and Myths about Women Highlight Mideast Conference
» 5/20/2007 - Open Mikes, Tough Questions and Brave Answers Characterize Day One of IWF Jordan Conference
» 5/15/2007 - First Ever Gathering in the Arab World of the International Women's Forum Draws Record Attendance
» 5/5/2007 - Women Leaders Gathering in the Mideast
» 4/20/2007 - Taking the Buyout
» 3/31/2007 - Where Have All the Women Gone?
» 12/5/2006 - Favorite Books
» 11/30/2006 - Old Economy Cultures Are Dead Weight in Race for 21st Century Talent
» 9/25/2006 - The World Watches Our Signals

Usage of content on this site for commercial purposes is strictly prohibited without written consent.